In an October 30, 2026, opinion, the Iowa Supreme Court held that the state's 2025 crypto-ATM refund duty does not apply to the 2024 transaction behind an operator's seized-cash claim. The court reversed the denial of a Bitcoin ATM operator's claim to $11,500 and sent the case back for further proceedings. It did not order anyone to pay the operator.
Operators now have a binding Iowa precedent against applying the refund obligation in Iowa Code section 533C.1004 to transactions that predate the law. But the $11,500 has already left state custody. A judge released it to the scam victim in a separate proceeding in December 2025, and the supreme court did not order him to return it.
The claim now belongs to CoinFlip, which acquired it from Bitcoin Depot's bankruptcy estate.
Court: Iowa Supreme Court
Decided: October 30, 2026
Docket: No. 25-1639 (published opinion)
Original claimant: Bitcoin Depot
Current claimant: GDP Holdings d/b/a Coinflip (via asset purchase agreement with Bitcoin Depot's bankruptcy estate)
Statute at issue: Iowa Code § 533C.1004 (refund provision enacted in 2025 through SF 449)
Disposition: Denial of claim reversed; remanded for further proceedings
A 2024 transaction falls outside the 2025 refund duty
Law enforcement seized $11,500 in cash tied to a 2024 Bitcoin ATM transaction. Bitcoin Depot claimed the cash, but the district court denied its claim based in part on the refund duty Iowa enacted in 2025. According to the supreme court's account, Judge Dalrymple's written ruling, dated August 19, treated § 533C.1004(8) as in effect when Bitcoin Depot applied for the seized cash. It found that the provision gave VanderWerf a superseding refund remedy and denied the application.
The supreme court rejected that reasoning. Iowa Code § 533C.1004 contains no express retroactivity provision and cannot defeat a claim arising from a transaction completed before the law took effect, the court held in its published opinion. SF 449 was signed May 19, 2025, and took effect upon enactment, according to the Iowa Legislature's bill history and the bill's text; a separate provision says it applies to operators on or after July 1, 2025. A later filing or hearing does not bring an earlier transaction under the 2025 provision. The transaction date controls.
The bill requires full refunds for qualifying fraudulently induced transactions, subject to proof and reports to the operator and a government or law-enforcement agency. For new consumers, it covers transactions in their first 30 days if reported within 90 days of the last transaction in that period; for existing consumers, the 90 days runs from the transaction for which a refund is sought.
The court also said the operator was entitled to the cash under its earlier ruling in a prior Bitcoin Depot seized-property case, Bitcoin Depot Operating, LLC v. Carlson (In re Property Seized for Forfeiture from Bitcoin Depot Operating, LLC), 21 N.W.3d 157 (Iowa 2025). That legal conclusion does not settle what the operator can recover. The district court must address that question on remand.
The cash left State custody ten months before the ruling
On December 18, 2025, Judge Linda Fangman ordered the cash returned to scam victim Gary VanderWerf in a separate proceeding (Property Seized re: VanderWerf, Gary Lee, docket SPCR001224), according to the opinion. VanderWerf appeared without counsel, and the order was granted based on the State's agreement. Bitcoin Depot received no notice of that order. Counsel told the supreme court the funds had been released.
The supreme court did not reverse the release order. VanderWerf was not a party to the appeal, and the opinion does not order him to repay anything. The court said Bitcoin Depot could challenge the validity of Judge Fangman's order on remand. The district court must decide first what remedies, if any, are available for the arguably premature release.
What the opinion does and does not do:
- Does: hold the 2025 refund statute cannot defeat this claim based on a 2024 transaction
- Does: recognize the operator's entitlement under the court's earlier seized-property ruling
- Does not: order payment of $11,500 to CoinFlip or anyone else
- Does not: order the victim to return the released cash
- Does not: set any restitution priority between victims and operators over this cash
- Does not: decide how other states' differently worded refund laws apply
Three justices would have separated refunds from ownership
The majority declined to decide whether a valid statutory refund claim arising from a post-enactment transaction would affect an operator's claim to seized property. That question remains open for disputes involving post-2025 transactions.
Three concurring justices would treat a refund claim under the statute as an unsecured claim against the operator, separate from ownership of the seized cash. Their reasoning favors operators, but it is not the court's holding and does not bind lower courts.
CoinFlip bought this claim out of Bitcoin Depot's bankruptcy
According to the opinion, Bitcoin Depot filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, making its claim for return of the seized $11,500 an asset of the bankruptcy estate. GDP Holdings d/b/a Coinflip acquired the claim through an asset purchase agreement. The opinion gives no acquisition date or broader description of the purchased assets. Bitcoin Depot filed Chapter 11 in May 2026 and disclosed in a May 18 Form 8-K exhibit that its kiosk network had been taken offline.
Bitcoin Depot had no Iowa kiosks in our October 31 archive of CoinATMRadar listings, down from four on January 21.
CoinFlip, the claim's new owner, runs 49 active kiosks in Iowa per our location tracker (which combines CoinATMRadar with operator feeds), with one install and no removals in the last 30 days.
The opinion lists Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird and members of her office as counsel for the appellee. The attorney general's newsroom page lists October 30 releases about other matters but none about this decision.
Pre-2025 Iowa transactions fall outside the refund duty
Operators litigating pre-2025 Iowa seizures can cite a binding supreme court ruling that section 533C.1004 does not apply retroactively. The opinion does not say how many such cases are pending, and factual and procedural disputes will still vary from case to case.
For Iowans scammed through Bitcoin ATMs before SF 449 took effect, the 2025 refund duty is unavailable for those earlier transactions. Other claims, including criminal restitution or consumer-protection theories, were not before the court. Victims weighing their options can find guidance in our consumer protection resources.
Outside Iowa, the ruling carries persuasive weight at most. Other states' refund laws use different language. The holding rests on the absence of retrospective language in this statute; it is not a general exemption from fraud-protection laws.
Our earlier coverage of the oral argument is here.
The case returns to district court with the retroactivity question settled but no payment ordered. The district court must decide what remedy, if any, is available now that the $11,500 has been released to VanderWerf.